CafeMom All articles
Parenting

50 Moms Came Clean About the Lies They Tell Their Kids — and Zero Regrets Were Had

CafeMom
50 Moms Came Clean About the Lies They Tell Their Kids — and Zero Regrets Were Had

Photo: Lance Cpl. Devon Tindle, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Let's just say it out loud: every mom lies to her kids. Not the big, harmful kind. The other kind. The survival kind. The "because I cannot explain the concept of death to a four-year-old at 6:47 a.m. before I've had coffee" kind.

We asked 50 moms across the country to get brutally honest about the fibs, half-truths, and creative reframings they use on the daily — and not a single one of them came in ashamed. In fact, most of them were downright proud.

Here's what they had to say.

The Classics Never Die (Looking at You, Santa)

Unsurprisingly, the holiday industrial complex is responsible for a huge chunk of mom lies. And honestly? Most of these women are not sorry.

"Santa absolutely knows when you're being rude to your brother. He has cameras everywhere. Yes, even in the car," said Dani, a mom of three from outside Nashville. "Is it manipulation? Sure. Does it work from November through December 26th? One hundred percent."

The Santa lie was nearly universal — but moms got creative with the mythology. Some have entire extended universes: elves who report back, a naughty list that updates in real time, a Santa who personally texts mom. One mom from Phoenix admitted she "accidentally" let her son see her typing into her phone and told him she was sending Santa his behavior update. "He was an angel for two weeks," she said. "Two. Weeks."

The Tooth Fairy made a strong showing too, particularly around the going rate. "I told my daughter the Tooth Fairy charges a processing fee if you lose the tooth at school," said Melissa from Ohio. "We only had five dollars in the house and I needed to manage expectations."

The 'That Place Is Closed' Lie

If you've never told your child that a restaurant, store, or bounce house facility is "closed today," are you even a mom? This was the second most popular category of lies — and moms had systems.

"McDonald's is only open on Fridays in our house," said Renee, a mom of two from Atlanta. "My kids are six and eight and they still believe this. I will take this to my grave."

Others have gotten more elaborate. One mom said the toy section at Target "got moved" and she just... hasn't found it yet. Another told her son that the ice cream truck only comes when it's playing music, and when it's out of ice cream, it plays no music. "He hears that truck and just says, 'Aw, they're all out.' It's been three summers," she said.

Do these moms feel guilty? Not really. "My job is to keep everyone alive and reasonably happy," said Keisha from Charlotte. "If 'the park is closed for cleaning' buys me a peaceful Saturday morning, I'm calling that a win."

The Lies That Are Actually... Parenting?

Here's where things got interesting. A handful of moms drew a line between lies told for convenience and lies told with genuine intention — and they stood firmly behind the latter.

"I tell my daughter that when she's mean to her friends, her heart gets a little smaller," said Tara from Colorado. "Is it literally true? No. But is it teaching her empathy? Yes. I'll call it a metaphor and sleep just fine."

Several moms mentioned telling their kids that vegetables give you superpowers, that being kind makes you physically stronger, or that their imaginary friend "told mom" they were being rude. These aren't really lies, they argued — they're just parenting in a language kids actually understand.

Child development experts might actually back them up on this one. Research suggests that children under seven struggle to fully separate fantasy from reality anyway, and parents who use narrative and metaphor to teach values aren't necessarily being deceptive — they're being developmentally appropriate. So, yes, telling your kid that broccoli makes you run faster is arguably just... good communication.

The Lies They Actually Feel a Little Weird About

Not every fib came without a flicker of guilt. A few moms got honest about the ones that sit a little uneasy.

"I told my son his goldfish went to 'fish heaven' and then immediately replaced it with an identical fish before he got home from school," said Amanda from New Jersey. "He named the new fish the same name. I never corrected him. That was four fish ago."

"I tell my kids I don't know where the Halloween candy went," said one mom who asked to remain anonymous. "I know exactly where it went. I ate it. In the laundry room. While watching reality TV."

And then there's the genre of lie that every mom of a teenager recognizes: the "I had the same curfew" lie, the "I never did anything like that" lie, the "your grandma will find out" lie. These get shakier as kids get older and start fact-checking, but moms deploy them anyway.

"My teenager has definitely Googled some of the stuff I've claimed," laughed Priya from Seattle. "I'm just hoping she respects the hustle."

So Are We Bad Moms for This?

Short answer: absolutely not.

Every single mom we talked to — even the ones with a twinge of guilt — was clear that their lies came from a place of love, protection, or sheer exhaustion-driven necessity. And there's something worth noting here: we don't call it lying when we tell kids that thunder is "just clouds bumping together" or that the boo-boo will stop hurting "in just a minute." We call it comfort.

The line between a harmful lie and a helpful one isn't always about the literal truth. It's about intent, impact, and whether you're building your kid up or tearing them down. Telling a five-year-old that Santa is real? Probably fine. Telling a child something that damages their self-worth or keeps them in the dark about something they genuinely need to know? That's a different conversation entirely.

Most of the lies these moms told fell squarely in the "harmless, hilarious, and honestly kind of genius" category.

The Lie They All Agreed On

At the end of our conversations, we asked each mom: is there one lie you tell yourself — not your kids — that keeps you going?

The answer, almost universally? "I'm doing a good job."

And here's the thing: that one? That one's actually true.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Parenting Rules These 50 Moms Threw Out the Window — and Their Families Are Better For It

The Parenting Rules These 50 Moms Threw Out the Window — and Their Families Are Better For It

Real Moms Are Done Apologizing for These Kitchen Shortcuts — and Honestly, Same

Real Moms Are Done Apologizing for These Kitchen Shortcuts — and Honestly, Same

Real Moms Spill How They're Raising Money-Smart Kids — Plus the Financial Lessons They Wish They'd Learned Way Earlier

Real Moms Spill How They're Raising Money-Smart Kids — Plus the Financial Lessons They Wish They'd Learned Way Earlier